|
Sometimes, you can judge a book by its cover. The 2009 Transportation MAP
- Metropolitan Atlanta Performance - Report released in October is available here. It offers a "snapshot" of performance
relative to mobility, transit accessibility, air quality and safety. Yet it's
the cover picture that paints a thousand words.
The
photograph shows the crowded regular lanes of the Downtown Connector, the spot
in the center of Atlanta where Interstates 75 and 85 merge. The high-occupancy
vehicle (HOV) lanes are practically empty; a lone bus travels down one HOV lane;
the HOV entrance ramp is barely occupied and the regular entrance ramp is
clogged. The report cites improvement overall, but the cover epitomizes metro
Atlanta's costly congestion.
The
lesson: Metro Atlanta's commuters tend to be solo drivers; transit is not a
competitive mode if it is caught in the same rush-hour traffic, and HOV lanes do
not hold promise as an attractive alternative.
Clearly,
traffic problems are both a sign of a thriving economy and of poor planning.
But throwing good money after bad or tackling every challenge with the same
level of enthusiasm and funding is not good policy. Including these 10
principles in transportation decision-making, on the other hand, will produce
results.
-
Focus on
mobility, not livability, "sustainability" or other liabilities to congestion
relief. Don't use transportation policy as a social engineering tool to coerce
people out of their vehicles into public transit or into
higher-density/live-work-play areas. Transportation problems must be resolved
with transportation solutions. Nor should environmental policy masquerade as
transportation policy. Government must allow the market to work, acknowledge
citizens' choices and work to improve their mobility.
-
Prioritize resources based on demand for a particular mode of transportation.
For example, 78 percent of Georgia workers drove to work alone in 2006 (down 3
percentage points from 2002); 12 percent carpooled (up 1 point); 2 percent took
public transportation (down 1 point) and 2.54 percent of worked from home in
2006 (up from 1.9 percent). Clearly, roads must come first; other modes should
not be disproportionately funded.
-
Understand the freight network is the backbone of Georgia's economy. Smoothing
freight passage by rail, road, sea or air will ensure economic growth. For
example, when rail capacity is relinquished to commuter rail service, it takes a
toll on freight capacity. That eventually forces more freight onto trucks,
clogging roads.
-
Facilitate private sector participation. Projected funding shortfalls in
infrastructure operations and maintenance are huge; finding funds for
enhancements is an even greater challenge. Not only can the private sector
provide funds, it can expedite projects. Encourage tolling, concessions and
other public-private initiatives wherever possible. That includes private
transit.
-
Help
commuters consider the value of their trip. Tolls are not just a fund-raising
tool. They also encourage commuters to decide when, whether and where to plan
their trip. A trip along an improved arterial road may be a lengthier but
cheaper choice than the tolled highway lane, which adds lane capacity on the
highway. Dynamic charges on a tolled road - perhaps changing by time of day -
become congestion insurance and encourage carpooling.
-
Building
roads is not the only tool to improving mobility. Technology plays an awesome
role. Intelligent highway systems provide real-time information, preventing
backups; synchronized traffic lights improve traffic flow and bus trip times;
ramp meters improve highway flow.
-
Target the roads less
traveled. Mobility improves and capacity is added when unnecessary traffic
is diverted. Viable outlying routes that divert through traffic - freight
and automobiles (such as Florida-bound tourists) - would
improve traffic flow without having to add lanes in the Atlanta urban area where
additional right-of-way is cost-prohibitive.
-
Look to
alternative funding for transportation. Georgia's motor fuel tax (7.5 cents) is
not indexed to inflation. With increasing costs and fuel efficiency, user fees
are falling short. Taking the fuel tax to an inflation-indexed percentage per
gallon can help in the near term. Mileage-based charges, tolling and private
sector investment are long-term options.
-
Demand
an end to pork. Transportation policy and funding must focus on moving people
from point A to Point B as quickly, efficiently and cost-effectively as
possible. Congress' penchant for earmarking funds to certain, largely local and
barely transportation-related projects takes money and focus away from a
comprehensive statewide approach.
-
Plan ahead. Think Northern Arc. Who thought it was clever to merge two
interstates in downtown Atlanta? Just because the region is not currently ready
for high-speed rail does not mean that it will never be. Right-of-way
acquisition should be processed with Georgia's future in mind.
Benita M. Dodd is vice
president of the Georgia Public Policy Foundation, an independent think tank
that proposes practical, market-oriented approaches to public policy to improve
the lives of Georgians. Nothing written here is to be construed
as necessarily reflecting the views of the Georgia Public Policy Foundation or
as an attempt to aid or hinder the passage of any bill before the U.S. Congress
or the Georgia Legislature.
|